Insights · Workplace guidance · 4 minute read

When to Teach and When to Walk Away

A bad decision can reveal a gap in knowledge or a breach of trust. The way someone handles the facts and corrects the record can help you decide what to do next.

By Vitaver Staffing ·

The same bad decision can have two different causes

A project lead reports that a system is ready. During a review, the team can find no record of a passing recovery test. The lead may have misunderstood what counted as passing. Or the lead may have known the test had failed and reported a pass anyway. The error in the report is identical. What you should do about it depends on how it got there.

In John Galt’s speech in Atlas Shrugged, Ayn Rand distinguishes errors of knowledge from breaches of morality. She makes willingness to correct the mistake central to that distinction. Someone can act in good faith on incomplete information and reach the wrong conclusion. Falsifying a result or deliberately avoiding evidence is a choice. That is why one case calls for teaching and the other calls for a decision about trust.

Teach when the person is willing to learn

Start by establishing what the person knew when they made the decision. Ask them to show the requirement they were working from and the evidence they used. In the recovery example, the lead might have thought a successful backup satisfied the requirement. Show them what the team actually needed to demonstrate, give them a way to run the test, and ask them to update the report. You have learned something about their judgment when they can explain the distinction and apply it at the next release.

People can be embarrassed or defensive at first. Give them a fair chance to check the facts and repair the error. Look for a correction that reaches the people who received the original claim. If the skill gap persists despite a good-faith effort, you may still need to reassign the work. Reliability matters for the role, and a lack of proficiency has its own remedy.

Walk away when the facts establish bad faith

Now take the second version. A reviewer finds a message showing the project lead knew the test had failed, followed by a passing result the lead entered manually. The lead then asks the tester to keep the failed run out of the record. Another lesson on how to run a recovery test would miss the problem. The lead already knew what the test showed and acted to conceal it.

Once deliberate deception is established, you can end a voluntary relationship on that evidence. You can stop negotiating a deal that depends on assurances you have good reason to distrust. At work, correct the record, protect the people relying on it, and have the person with authority review or close the matter. Finish any necessary handoff. Repeated discussion is an expensive way to postpone a decision when the relevant facts are already clear.

In Reflections, Idries Shah cites the proverb, “The answer to a fool is silence,” and adds that nearly any other answer comes to the same thing in the long run. The practical lesson is to stop spending time on an argument when the other person keeps evading the very facts a resolution would require. Take the action the situation calls for and let the discussion end.

Use the same standard on yourself

Before deciding which case you face, ask what evidence would change your mind. Disagreement, a clumsy explanation, and an inconvenient fact can all feel like resistance if you are invested in being right. Give the other person room to show that your account is incomplete. If it is, correct your own account as plainly as you would ask them to correct theirs.

When the evidence is incomplete, limit what depends on the disputed claim while you check it. When someone takes responsibility and shows the correction in their work, invest in them. When the evidence establishes deceit, protect the work and take your time elsewhere. You can keep pursuing a worthy goal through people who are willing to deal in facts.

← All Insights