Insights · Workplace guidance · 4 minute read

Why Empty Praise Fails to Motivate

A leader can ask for applause. The willingness to take responsibility and do good work comes from the person. Give people room to exercise it and recognize what they actually achieve.

By Vitaver Staffing ·

What applause can conceal

“They pretend to pay us, and we pretend to work.” In a 1988 BBC Reith Lecture, historian Geoffrey Hosking used that joke to illustrate a bargain workers recognized in the late Soviet economy. Public life also had its expected displays of approval. Anthropologist Alexei Yurchak describes how official speeches, slogans, and rituals became routine in the late Soviet period. People held a range of views, including sincere attachments and private doubts. The joke captures the cynicism that can grow when people are expected to celebrate one version of reality and live with another.

At work, the scale is different and the temptation is familiar. A leader asks for enthusiasm. Colleagues exchange compliments, awards are handed out on schedule, and the room applauds. If the person receiving an award cannot say what earned it, the people watching probably cannot either. They learn which response is expected at the next meeting. The people who did the hard work also learn how little evidence the award requires.

Take character seriously and give people room to use it

Look for the people who take pride in fixing a problem, learning a difficult skill, or keeping a promise when nobody is watching. That willingness comes from the person. It shows up in choices over time, including what they do when an assignment gets tedious or a mistake would be easier to hide. An organization can give people reasons to care and room to use their judgment. Each person still has to take ownership of the effort.

Psychologists Marylène Gagné and Edward Deci distinguish between doing work because the activity itself is satisfying and doing it because the person values what it achieves. A recruiter may find a good deal of satisfaction in finding the right person for a difficult role. The same recruiter may find a verification call tedious and still make it carefully because they value keeping promises to a client. Both reasons can sustain work the individual is willing to own.

Fair pay, workable conditions, and the authority to solve real problems give people a reason to trust the organization’s side of the bargain. If employees tell you that a supervisor keeps blocking routine decisions, assign someone to fix that. If people say a promise about workload was broken, address the promise. Ask what changed after the conversation. Repeating the company’s values at a meeting leaves those questions unanswered.

Recognize work that actually happened

In a review of experimental studies, Deci, Richard Koestner, and Richard Ryan found that positive feedback could increase interest, and that the way it was delivered mattered. In practice, useful recognition identifies the action, why it mattered, and whose work made it possible. When a recruiter spots a licensing discrepancy before a candidate is submitted, for example, thank them for checking the source and resolving the discrepancy with the candidate. Give credit to anyone who helped. The rest of the team can see which habit is worth repeating.

An award carries a stronger claim than a thank-you. Say what merits it and name the evidence. If the evidence falls short this quarter, save the award for work that meets the standard. A simple, specific thank-you on an ordinary Tuesday can mean more than a plaque presented because the agenda had a slot for it.

Look for initiative after the meeting

This is an application of Signal vs. Noise in The Vitaver Playbook. Look at what people do when attention returns to the work. Who volunteers to own a real problem? Who raises bad news early? Who follows through on a promise? Give people room to do those things, including room to disagree with a supervisor about what is getting in the way. When you see a problem, put someone in charge of correcting it and check the result with the people affected.

Ask a team member what part of the work they are proud to put their name on. Then make sure they have the authority, time, and tools to do it well. If they deliver something worth recognizing, tell them exactly what you saw.

← All Insights