A manager can settle a question in ten seconds. The more valuable result, when time allows, is a colleague who can handle the next one independently. Start with “What would you do?” Then let the person propose a course of action before you offer yours.
Ask for a recommendation and give it room to develop
Imagine a recruiter asks which of two technicians to put forward for a client interview. Both meet the stated requirements. One described how they resolved the kind of overnight incident the client needs covered. The other’s notes name a relevant tool but leave their role in a similar incident unclear. Before choosing a candidate, the staffing manager asks, “What would you recommend?” A reasonable answer might be to send the first candidate and ask the second for a comparable example before deciding.
Follow with “Why would you do it that way?” If the recruiter is leaning on years of experience or familiarity with a product name, ask which evidence shows the person could handle the assignment. Then ask “What would make you change your mind?” The recruiter might realize that the second candidate never had the same opportunity to demonstrate the skill. Apply the same job-related questions and standard to both. If the recruiter reaches a well-supported choice different from yours, hear it out before deciding whether to intervene.
Let the person test and own a decision
You can use the same sequence with a project engineer, team lead or new manager:
- “What would you do?” Ask for one recommendation and give the person time to form it.
- “Why that way?” Ask for the outcome they want, the strongest evidence and the main assumption.
- “Is there a better result we could aim for?” Ask for the strongest alternative and the tradeoff. If the choice is hard to reverse, agree on the smallest useful test first.
- “How will you know it worked?” Have the person name the observable result and decide when to check it.
Then say who decides. In the recruiting example, the manager can authorize the recruiter to make the shortlist against the agreed standard and set a time to review the evidence. If the client’s requirements change or the recruiter lacks the agreed authority, the manager makes the reserved decision. Explain that boundary so the next question comes with a recommendation and the right person can act on it.
Teach with questions when there is time to think
If someone needs a fact, give the fact. If a decision must be made immediately and it belongs to you, make it. Come back later and ask what the person saw and what they would do in a similar situation. If they lack information that only you have, give it to them early. If a colleague repeatedly brings you choices they are equipped and authorized to make, ask them to bring a recommendation and the evidence next time. Pair that expectation with the authority to act.
The U.S. Army’s guide to counseling, coaching and mentoring describes using open questions to help people work through problems. In Mike Rother’s demonstration of a Coaching Kata cycle, questions make the learner’s thinking visible so the coach can give feedback suited to the situation.
The familiar saying about giving someone a fish and teaching them to fish applies to judgment too. This is the Vitaver Playbook’s emphasis on ownership in practice. At the next review, ask the colleague to explain a decision they made, what happened and what they would change. Give them room to make the next comparable decision, then have them use the same questions to help someone else grow.