Insights · Career guidance · 5 minute read

Remote or on-site: which gives you a better chance to advance?

Decide where to work by examining how your team teaches, assigns stretch work and promotes people. Separate promotion prospects from layoff risk.

By Vitaver Staffing · Published

If you are new to a profession or pursuing your first leadership role, and the people who can teach you and entrust you with harder work meet in one place, our advice is to spend time there with them. Choose the design review, the difficult customer visit or the shift handoff. Commuting on a day when those colleagues are elsewhere buys little. For an experienced specialist on a distributed team, the call where a customer makes a decision may be the most valuable room to enter.

The question is where you can learn the next job, do part of it, and earn the confidence of people who will vouch for your work. Promotion and job security deserve separate answers.

People like working with people they like. What earned that preference?

Think about a restaurant you return to. The owner’s ethnicity or gender may never enter your mind. You remember that the meal is good, that you can get out in time for the theater, and that when the kitchen made a mistake, someone fixed it without making it your problem. You like the place because experience gave you reasons to trust it.

There is a workplace equivalent. A project manager may ask for a particular engineer because she delivers bad news early, disagrees without humiliating anyone and stays with a problem until the customer can operate again. Being pleasant to work with has business value when you can explain what the person does that helps the work. But choosing dinner is a personal preference. Awarding a promotion is a decision on behalf of an organization. “We have lunch together” says nothing about whether someone can lead a release. Gender, ethnicity and other personal characteristics have no place in that judgment. Familiarity can creep in even when nobody intends it: the manager may simply have seen one engineer handle a difficult customer and never offered the other engineer that opportunity.

What the evidence says about promotions

Two studies help explain why employees hear conflicting advice. In a randomized Chinese call-center experiment, volunteers assigned to home working handled more work, yet had a lower promotion rate after accounting for performance. Doing the current job well and being chosen for a larger one were different outcomes in that setting. Bloom and colleagues, The Quarterly Journal of Economics.

A later randomized trial at Trip.com involved 1,612 employees and a hybrid schedule that allowed two days at home each week. Researchers found no evidence of a promotion difference over the next two years, and fewer employees quit. That finding concerns a particular hybrid arrangement. It cannot tell a fully remote employee what will happen at a firm where every department head works on-site. Bloom, Han and Liang, Nature.

One reason to seek time with colleagues is the feedback you can get there. A study of software engineers at one large company found that people sitting near teammates received more coding feedback, with gains concentrated among younger and less-tenured engineers. For someone learning the craft, that suggests a specific request: “Could we review my design together before I implement it?” Ask for the same review by video if that is where your most knowledgeable teammate works. Emanuel, Harrington and Pallais, The Power of Proximity to Coworkers.

Job security is a different calculation

A lower quit rate tells you that more people chose to stay. It does not tell you who was selected for a layoff. Neither promotion study establishes that commuting protects your job. A reliable employee can lose a position when a contract ends. An on-site technician may be essential while equipment is being installed and have little assigned work after acceptance. A remote engineer may own the service the customer has just renewed. Reverse those assignments and the employment outlook changes with them.

If security concerns you, ask your manager two questions: “Which work is funded after this milestone?” and “What skill would qualify me for that work?” If the next assignment genuinely requires physical presence, find that out early enough to decide whether you want it. Where a customer values your contribution, make the result visible in the ordinary course of work: a tested handoff, a resolved incident, or confirmation that the customer can now do something it previously could not. None is insurance against a budget cut. Each gives your manager a fact to work with when staffing the next project.

Find out how advancement happens in your organization

Look at the last two people promoted into the role you want. What responsibility did each take on beforehand? Who saw the work? Could a remote colleague have received the same assignment? Ask your manager, “What decision do you need to see me make independently before you would recommend me?” That answer is more useful than a general assurance that the company supports flexible work.

Then choose an arrangement for the next project. If the gap is customer judgment, join an experienced colleague for a consequential customer meeting and own the follow-up. If your team is distributed, volunteer to lead the next remote incident review, write down the decision and ask the service owner for feedback. If you work hybrid, coordinate days with the people you need to learn from and protect uninterrupted time for the work you owe them. Agree with your manager on a date to review what you demonstrated and what responsibility comes next.

Managers have a corresponding duty. Offer consequential assignments across work arrangements whenever the job permits, and name the evidence behind a promotion recommendation. If you can say, “I would put this person in front of our most demanding customer because I saw how they handled these two situations,” you have a defensible reason for your confidence. If all you can say is, “I know them better,” give the other person a fair chance to do the work.

This applies the Signal vs. Noise practice from The Vitaver Playbook. The strongest reason to go on-site is that something valuable happens there that you would otherwise miss. The strongest reason to choose remote work is that you can do excellent work there and still participate in the decisions, relationships and learning that lead to your next role.

Questions for discussion

  1. Which part of the next role could you demonstrate on the project you have now?
  2. How do remote colleagues get access to consequential assignments on your team?
← All Insights