The American Revolution broke with British rule and retained parts of English legal practice. The French Revolution abolished the monarchy and swept away feudal privileges. Yet French revolutionaries also preserved laws during the transition, and the restored monarchy kept a major reform in force. Both histories offer practical evidence for a question leaders face when replacing a system: What must change, and what work must still get done the next morning?
Virginia changed who had authority and kept rules its courts could use
Virginia’s revolutionary convention made a selective choice in 1776. In an ordinance printed in Hening’s Statutes at Large, the convention kept English common law, certain earlier English statutes and existing Virginia laws in force where compatible with the convention’s actions, pending changes by Virginia’s legislature. The break with Britain changed where authority came from while giving courts a working body of rules. Later, the Seventh Amendment to the U.S. Constitution preserved civil jury trial in specified common-law suits.
American continuity involved hard breaks and grave injustices. The federal Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation and still carried forward existing national debts and commitments in Article VI. The original constitutional text also accommodated slavery, including through the three-fifths provision for representation and direct taxation. Calling something familiar or durable tells us little about whether it deserves to survive.
France changed regimes and kept institutions running
In 1789, France’s Constituent Assembly adopted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen alongside decrees abolishing feudal rights. The National Convention’s meeting record for September 21, 1792 shows two decisions made on the same day. It abolished royalty and directed that laws still in force be applied provisionally and existing taxes continue to be collected. Louis XVI was executed in January 1793. The political break was profound, and the new authorities still needed ordinary government to function.
The constitutional act of May 1804 made Napoleon emperor. The Civil Code adopted that year consolidated civil laws. When Louis XVIII returned in 1814, Article 68 of his constitutional charter expressly kept the Civil Code and existing laws compatible with the charter. The Bourbon Restoration brought the dynasty back under changed terms. The documents show a mix of rupture and continuity. They offer no single explanation for why either country took the course it did.
Decide what to carry forward before you switch systems
This is an application of the Vitaver Playbook’s Mission First principle. Judge each element by the work it enables, the people or assets it protects and the evidence that it will still serve the mission. Consider a manufacturer replacing a purchasing system whose vendor no longer supports it. The manufacturer may need a new platform and a simpler approval flow. It still needs to know who authorized an order, what the supplier delivered and why a payment was approved.
- Retire or isolate what creates the problem. The system owner identifies the component that needs replacing and any use that has to stop. Give a newly introduced workaround an end date and an owner.
- Preserve a function with a clear purpose. The purchasing and finance owners identify the records and safeguards people need. Rebuild them in the new system or retain an approved way to retrieve them.
- Make temporary carryover explicit. If the team needs the old order lookup during the transition, decide who can use it and when to shut it down. Have a second person retrieve an old order and reconcile a new one through receipt and payment.
A clean start can be justified when the core system cannot support the mission. Before authorizing one, give the replacement an owner, list the functions the organization must be able to perform on day one and test them through a real work sequence. Use the results to decide which pieces you can safely leave behind.