In “Fixed Thinking,” a story in Idries Shah’s The Pleasantries of the Incredible Mulla Nasrudin, the Mulla gives his age as forty. His questioner remembers getting precisely that answer two years earlier. Nasrudin sees nothing embarrassing about the arithmetic. He takes pride in being a man who stands by his word. John Zada’s account of the story.
The joke turns on a distinction worth taking into a business meeting. Forty was an observation with a date attached. Nasrudin treats it as a promise. If he really was forty then, the honest answer two years later is forty-two. The first answer can remain perfectly true about then while becoming the wrong answer about now.
Remember why a good decision was good
Imagine a utility preparing to replace equipment across several sites. During the installation, it asks a staffing firm for engineers who can be on-site every weekday. The hiring manager has a sound reason: an engineer must inspect the equipment and sign off before each site can return to service. The recruiter writes “five days on-site” into the search. The hires do the work. The project succeeds.
A year later the recruiter reopens the same requisition. Strong applicants keep asking what requires five days at the plant. The team’s first answer is, “That’s what the client wants.” Someone finally calls the person running the sites. Installation finished months ago. Today the team reviews operating data remotely and dispatches an engineer for planned tests or faults. The old requirement had an owner and a reason. Both are missing from the copied job description.
The recruiter should not quietly advertise the role as remote. A useful call to the authorized hiring manager would be: “We asked for daily attendance because each installation needed an inspection. Which duties require physical presence now, how quickly must someone get there, and who can approve a revised schedule?” The answer might still require someone local. But the firm can now recruit against the work the client actually needs and give candidates an accurate account of it.
A changed fact, a mistaken assumption, or a different preference?
These call for different explanations. If installation ended Friday, say what changed and when. If you discover the contract never required five days on-site and your team added that condition, own the mistake and correct it. If management simply prefers more people in the office, present that as a choice and explain the tradeoff. Calling all three “changing circumstances” makes it hard for employees to know whether they can rely on the next instruction.
Competition deserves the same discipline. Suppose a rival promises qualified candidates in two days. That establishes what the rival advertises. It tells you little about whether the buyer values speed above screening quality or whether the rival delivers. Before changing your own service promise, ask the buyer which delay cost them a qualified hire. If the answer is that interviews sat unapproved for a week, a faster submission promise would solve the wrong problem.
Rules and laws require an additional check. A forwarded summary that says “the rules have changed” is a reason to investigate. Have the responsible compliance or legal reviewer check the official text, its effective date, which work it covers, and what happens to existing commitments. Give the people doing the work an approved instruction and an effective date. A new customer need may justify asking to amend a contract. The customer still deserves the service already agreed unless and until the terms change.
Give important decisions a condition for review
When making a decision with a long life, put the reason beside the instruction. In the utility example, one line would have spared a year of inherited certainty: “Daily attendance covers physical installation sign-offs. When the final site is accepted, the service manager will confirm coverage for the operating phase before the next vacancy is posted.” A new employee can understand that line, notice when it expires, and take the question to someone who can settle it.
When you reverse a decision, offer the same clarity in public: “I required daily attendance during installation. That work ended last month. The client has confirmed the new response window, and our revised posting takes effect Monday. Current staff should follow their existing schedules until their manager confirms any change with them.” Employees hear what justified the original decision, what evidence changed it, and what to do tomorrow morning. They can also question the decision if one of those facts is wrong.
This applies The Method from The Vitaver Playbook: identify the question that would settle the matter and take it to the person who can answer it. At the next review of a long-standing rule, try asking, “What had to be true for us to choose this, and when did we last check?” Sometimes the answer will justify keeping the rule. Sometimes the person with the best answer will be the newest employee, still curious enough to wonder how the company can possibly be forty again.