Insights · Hiring guidance · 4 minute read

When should you rehire a former employee?

A past employee wants to return. Weigh what you know from working together, why they left, and what each side can now offer.

By Vitaver Staffing · Published

A former employee calls on the day a difficult vacancy opens. “I’d like to come back,” he says. His old manager remembers the weekend he rescued a customer project. The team remembers him fondly. It is tempting to make an offer before the call ends. One question is worth asking first: Knowing what we know from his first time here, would we choose him for the work we need done now?

Rehiring makes sense when the person’s record and current abilities support that choice, both sides understand why the first employment ended, and the conditions that matter this time are ones both can actually meet. Leaving for a better opportunity is no betrayal. Wanting to return is no guarantee that the old difficulty has gone away.

Start with the vacancy you actually have

Imagine a field engineer who left a services company to learn system design. Eighteen months later, she wants to return. Her former supervisor has an opening with the same title she used to hold. But the work has changed: the engineer now has to plan installations, coordinate vendors and hand over a design another technician can maintain. Her old record tells the supervisor how she handles a broken system under pressure. It says much less about whether she can design one.

Ask her to walk through a recent design decision using material she can share. What constraint shaped her choice? What did the receiving technician need? What would she change on the next installation? Give an internal applicant and an outside candidate a comparable opportunity to demonstrate the same skills. The returning engineer can earn credit twice over: for work the company saw firsthand and for capabilities she has acquired since. Neither requires lowering the standard.

Ask what sent the person away, and what is bringing them back

These are two different questions. “I miss the team” is a perfectly good reason to call. It leaves open whether the job is one the person wants to do. A useful conversation sounds like this: “When you left, you wanted more design work. Which parts of this opening appeal to you? It still includes travel two weeks most months. How does that compare with what you want now?” The manager owes an equally candid answer about what has changed inside the company.

Sometimes nothing needs fixing. An employee left on good terms to complete a degree, or a project ended and the company had no work to offer. A suitable opening and a good prior record may be enough. Other departures leave a question that deserves evidence. If repeated missed handoffs mattered last time, ask how the person now manages a handoff and for a recent example. If the company repeatedly promised a promotion it never funded, the burden of proof belongs to the company. Show the approved role and authority before inviting someone to rely on that promise again.

Research offers a reason to resist easy assumptions. In one longitudinal study of people rehired into management positions, returning managers performed similarly to internal and external hires in the first year. The other groups improved more over time. Those findings concern the managers studied. For an individual hiring decision, ask what the person can do today and what they will need to learn next. Arnold and colleagues, Journal of Management.

Know when a familiar face is the wrong choice

Suppose the travel requirement drove the engineer away, she still wants a local assignment, and the service contract still requires travel. “We’ll work something out” merely postpones the same departure. Specify the arrangement the company can deliver or decline with a clear explanation. Likewise, if a documented breach of trust involved a duty essential to the new position, familiarity and a warm reunion cannot settle that question. Assess the relevant facts consistently and give the person a chance to address them.

Consider the colleague who took over after the departure. Did that person improve the work and become a credible applicant? They deserve the same hearing. And if the former employee expects to resume an old title or supervise people who now lead the team, settle that before the offer. The current team should hear who owns which decisions from its manager. It should never have to discover the arrangement by watching two people give conflicting instructions.

Make the second start a real start

Before either side commits, confirm the duties, reporting line, compensation, worksite, travel and start date in writing. In the field engineer example, agree that her first assignment will be to design one installation and hand it to a technician who can complete the work from her instructions. Name the person who will review it. On her first day, show her the tools, procedures and customer commitments that changed while she was away. At the first project review, ask both her and the receiving technician where the handoff worked and where it broke down.

This draws on the Mission First practice from The Vitaver Playbook. A former employee brings something valuable to a hiring decision: both sides have already seen each other at work. Use that knowledge honestly, including what each side got wrong. The best reason to say “welcome back” is that you can both explain why the next chapter makes sense on its own terms.

Questions for discussion

  1. What did you learn from the first employment that matters for this opening?
  2. Which condition of a return would you want confirmed in writing?
← All Insights