Insights · Workplace guidance · 4 minute read

The Wrong Forest and the CEO’s Duty to Challenge Complacency

A good manager improves how the team does the work. A leader also asks whether the work is still worth doing. A CEO should make that question safe to ask and hard to ignore.

By Vitaver Staffing ·

“Wrong tree.” “Wrong forest.”

A manager sees the crew cutting the wrong tree and tells them where to work. A leader looks at the crew’s assignment and asks whether the company should be working in that forest at all. Stephen R. Covey illustrated a similar distinction in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, where a leader surveys the direction of the work and calls out, “Wrong jungle!” A company needs both types of judgment. The same person may exercise both during a single morning.

Imagine a technology firm that gets better at producing detailed monthly system reports. The manager reduces errors and puts the reports out on schedule. The CEO asks customers which decisions those reports help them make. The answer may be that they use two details to avoid an outage and rarely open the rest. The firm now has a different question to answer. Could the team deliver those details in time for customers to prevent an interruption? The manager can help make that service reliable. The leader has to be willing to change what the team is building.

Make everybody a little uncomfortable

A CEO has a duty to challenge settled assumptions, including their own. Ask why a line of work deserves next year’s resources. Ask which customer would notice if a recurring activity disappeared. Ask the person closest to the work what they think management is missing. These questions are uncomfortable because familiar work, past decisions, and reputations may be tied up in the answers. Without that examination, conformity can keep a company busy long after customers begin to lose interest.

The useful discomfort is having to defend an assumption with evidence or reconsider it. People should be able to do that without humiliation or retaliation. In a study of 51 teams at a manufacturing company, Amy Edmondson found an association between psychological safety and team learning behavior. For a CEO, the practical implication is to make it possible for people to speak early when a test fails or when the boss’s preferred explanation leaves something out. Then act on what the evidence shows.

Show the team how to challenge you

Start a review by naming a decision you made and the assumption behind it. Say what would persuade you to reconsider. Let the people doing the work bring the customer evidence, including the evidence that complicates your case. If they have shown that your plan needs to change, say what changed your mind and make the decision in the room. If the evidence is incomplete, assign one person to obtain the missing fact and agree on a date to decide.

Run the same test on a proposal for change. Ask what problem it solves, how the team will know it worked, and what the company must protect during the trial. A current practice can deserve to stay if it still serves the mission. A new one earns a trial when the team can explain why it might work and how it will limit the cost of being wrong.

Give each review a consequence

Choose one product, process, or assumption that has escaped examination. Ask the manager what would make it work better and ask the leader what would make it worth doing at all. Put the resulting decision into the work. That might mean fixing a handoff, ending a report, or committing to test a different service. Give one person authority to act and a date to show the result. That is how a little discomfort can keep an organization alert enough to survive and improve.

← All Insights