Insights · Hiring guidance · 5 minute read

The Science of Compensation and the Power of a Why

Pay has to be enough to attract and retain the people who can do the work. Incentives also need to reward the judgment, effort, and quality the job actually requires.

By Vitaver Staffing ·

Separate the pay someone can count on from the bonus they can earn

A sound compensation plan has to answer two questions. Will people with the right skills take the job and stay? What will the plan lead them to pay more attention to once they are doing it? Base pay and incentives answer different parts of that problem. Too little dependable pay can make a role unattractive or make extra effort feel one-sided. An oversized bonus can put too much pressure on judgment or make one measured result crowd out the rest of the work.

Start with the work as it actually exists. Compare pay for similar responsibilities, skill requirements, locations, and schedules. Look at why people decline offers and why experienced employees leave. Before blaming discipline or interest, find out whether people can reasonably accept the terms and whether the team has kept the commitments it made. Those are things a manager can investigate.

What studies show at the low and high ends

In a field experiment, Sebastian Kube, Michel André Maréchal, and Clemens Puppe found that cutting workers’ expected wages reduced average output by more than 20 percent in that setting. The study detected no significant productivity gain from an equivalent increase. The result illustrates an asymmetry. Breaking a pay expectation can have a cost that a comparable increase does not automatically reverse. A higher base can still be the right choice for scarce expertise or retention. Judge the cost against what it buys for this role.

At the high end, pay design matters. In one experiment by Dan Ariely, Uri Gneezy, George Loewenstein, and Nina Mazar, very large performance rewards improved performance on a repetitive key-pressing task and hurt performance on a task that required arithmetic. This was an experiment with specific tasks and stakes. A company should take from it a question about its own work. Which decisions need calm judgment, and what happens to that judgment when a large payout depends on a single result?

There are settings where performance pay works well. Edward Lazear found that output rose at one auto-glass company after it adopted piece rates. Higher output reflected changes in worker effort and in who worked for the company. A broader review by Christopher Cerasoli and colleagues found intrinsic motivation was more closely associated with quality and incentives were a better predictor of quantity. These findings point to the importance of deciding what you want more of and checking what happens to quality at the same time.

What a “why” can do for the work

“When you have a why, you find a how” is a practical adaptation of a thought Friedrich Nietzsche expressed in Twilight of the Idols, in aphorism 12 of “Maxims and Arrows.” Viktor Frankl later quoted Nietzsche in Man’s Search for Meaning using the familiar English rendering “He who has a why to live for can bear almost any how.” Nietzsche’s point concerns bearing difficulty. At work, a reason worth taking seriously also helps people decide which difficulty is worth their effort and where to look for a solution.

A recruiter who understands why a client needs reliable overnight coverage has a reason to verify the candidate’s real availability, even when that means slowing down a submission. A credible reason for doing the work supports that judgment. Pay the person for the responsibilities the role carries and explain the outcome those responsibilities serve. Each belongs in the working agreement.

Test what the plan rewards

Suppose a staffing team rewards the number of résumés submitted. The company needs timely, qualified starts that hold up after the first week. Look at what the individual can influence, including the quality of the screening and the accuracy of commitments made to both sides. A hiring decision and its timing also depend on the client. Make any incentive simple enough for employees to explain and check, and decide which quality standard has to be met for a result to count.

Give the compensation owner a review date. Track offer acceptance, retention, quality, and the total cost of results before and after a change. If activity rises while errors or early departures rise with it, examine what the plan led people to optimize. If strong candidates consistently decline on pay, check the base before adding a contest or bonus. The useful range is the one that attracts the people the work needs and encourages the quality of effort the business can sustain.

← All Insights