Insights · Economics and policy · 7 minute read

When the Problem Ends, What Happens to the Mission?

A real purpose gives people a reason to act and a way to recognize success. The Cold War, the costs of self-defense and the design of poverty relief show what happens when the incentives of an organization and the needs of the people it serves diverge.

By Vitaver Staffing ·

A genuine reason to act gives people a way to make decisions when the instructions run out. A parent wants a child fed. A soldier wants the people at home to be safe. A worker wants enough control over earnings to plan a future. Circumstances can make action urgent. The purpose becomes their own when they can see what their effort protects or improves. Organizations have incentives of their own, including contracts, budgets and jobs. The test is what happens when the people an organization serves begin to need it less.

Arbatov asked what would happen if the adversary disappeared

In 1988, Soviet adviser Georgi Arbatov said, “We are going to do something terrible to you — we are going to deprive you of an enemy.” The line captured a paradox. A Soviet threat gave the United States a reason to maintain a large defense establishment. It also generated orders, jobs and research. The end of the confrontation gave the country a chance to ask which capabilities it still needed and which resources could go to work elsewhere. Contemporary reporting on Arbatov’s remark and Madeleine Albright’s later account.

The industrial effects were substantial. A 1995 GAO report put U.S. defense-industry employment about 35% below its 1987 peak, while overall output and nondefense employment grew over the period it reviewed. Communities and suppliers tied to military procurement faced real losses. Some capabilities proved valuable far beyond defense. ARPANET, for example, helped lay the foundation for the internet. The procurement work, the later commercial uses and the security objective are three different results. A program review should ask which of them justifies the next dollar. GAO’s report on defense spending and employment and DARPA’s history of ARPANET.

Golda Meir spoke about the price of being forced to fight

A remark often attributed to Meir distinguishes grieving one’s own dead from carrying the burden of having caused deaths on the other side. The remark circulates in several forms, commonly credited to a 1973 collection edited by Marie Syrkin. In a documented address to the Knesset after the 1973 war with Egypt and Syria, Meir said, “We are grievously impoverished by the loss of those who fell,” then discussed both deterrence and negotiations with Israel’s neighbors. The 1973 collection edited by Marie Syrkin and Meir’s March 1974 address.

Arbatov asked what would happen when a threat receded. Meir had to reckon with what a threat had required of people. Self-defense can give people a reason to acquire skills they never wanted to need. Their obligation to protect others can be deeply held, and they can still have to live with grief and the consequences of having used force. The value of the purpose comes from the lives it protects. That gives leaders a reason to ask what force can achieve, what harm it can cause and when diplomacy can serve the same purpose.

Design relief around the people who need it

During famine, the immediate job is to protect life. Food and treatment should reach people in time. Once the emergency eases, ask what will help households regain the ability to feed themselves and make their own choices. That could mean restoring access to land or markets, securing work or replacing tools lost in a crisis. People who depend on ongoing assistance because of lasting needs still deserve it. The right measure depends on the outcome the program exists to deliver. Integrated Food Security Phase Classification guidance.

A donor or public agency can build the wrong incentive into a program. If renewal depends mainly on caseload and money spent, helping people leave the program can make the next budget harder to defend. If renewal depends only on departures, the provider can improve its numbers by turning away people who still need help. Use outcomes after assistance changes, such as stable food access or household income, alongside evidence about who was served and who was left out. Ask the people using the program what keeps them from gaining more control over their lives.

Make progress pay

Ronald Reagan said that “work should be more rewarding than welfare” in a 1987 address. A practical way to test that principle is to compare what a household keeps before and after a raise. Imagine a parent earns an extra $200 a month and loses a $300 child-care subsidy. The household has $100 less before any change in taxes or work expenses. Turning down that raise can be a sound financial decision. A gradual benefit reduction can preserve a reason to take on more hours or responsibility. Reagan’s address and Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta analysis of benefit cliffs.

The evidence depends on program design. An analysis of seven randomized trials in six countries found no consistent reduction in work from the cash transfers studied. A separate six-country experiment combined temporary support with productive assets, training and coaching. On average, gains in household consumption persisted a year after the program ended. These are reasons to test a program’s actual effects and to distinguish work incentives from barriers such as lack of child care, equipment or a viable local market. Cash-transfer study and Livelihoods experiment.

This is an application of the Vitaver Playbook’s Mission First principle. At the next funding review, have the program owner say what should be different for the people served in six months, how they will check it and under what conditions the organization will be able to hand the work over or wind it down. Where support must continue, say what it protects and how recipients will retain a say in their next step.

← All Insights